Avalon Park 2025 Year in Review: What Changed for Landlords in 32828

For most Orlando neighborhoods, "year in review" comes down to two numbers: rent up X percent, vacancy down Y. Avalon Park's 2025 had a different number. It was five — as in the last five acres of a 28-year, 1,860-acre community. The master plan that built 32828 from cattle pasture to a downtown-with-a-Publix is finally running out of land.

Here's the short version. The last five acres in 32828 were slated for Stanley Martin townhomes and, likely, senior housing, and the developer turned growth attention east toward Daytona. Add it up and Avalon Park enters 2026 in a position it hasn't been in for a decade — with no new developer-led single-family supply coming behind it.

What actually happened in Avalon Park in 2025?

Three things, and they all point the same direction.

Stanley Martin Homes was expected to begin site development by the second quarter of 2025 on the southern half of the "Flagpole Lot" next to the Town Center. The plan is 90 townhomes. It's the largest new-construction announcement Avalon Park has seen in years, and it's also the last.

The northern half was planned for senior housing — a 118-unit senior living facility and an 88-unit age-targeted apartment building, with an expanded Cat's Claw Lane connecting to a new street called Avalon Lake Drive, per the GrowthSpotter coverage from mid-2024 that's tracked the entitlements since.

And the developer itself — Avalon Park Group — spent 2025 with its growth attention east, not here. Avalon Park Daytona, the 2,760-acre planned community west of I-95, kept moving through entitlement steps. By December 2025, Ormond Beach had rejected Daytona's $2.3 million settlement offer on the cross-municipal water dispute, meaning the project ended the year in active negotiation rather than active construction. That's not a setback for 32828 — it's a signal. The original community has matured. New product gets built elsewhere now.

What does the end of the master plan mean for 32828 rents?

It means the supply tap is closing. For a decade, Avalon Park landlords have priced rentals against a steady drip of new construction — new phases opening, new townhomes coming online, new apartments in the Town Center. Renewal conversations have always had a "the building down the street just opened" subtext.

From 2027 onward, that subtext goes away. The Stanley Martin townhomes are for-sale product, not rentals, so they compete on the purchase side, not against your 3BR lease.

The Avalon Park rental thesis for 2026 isn't "rents are spiking." Metro headwinds haven't gone away. The thesis is the comparison set stabilizes. The renter walking into your 3BR/2BA in Avalon South can still find a deal at an apartment community five miles away — but they can't find a brand-new SFR in 32828 that didn't exist last year. That hasn't been true since roughly 2016.

If you own a single-family rental in Avalon Park, this is the renewal cycle to set the next 24 months on. See where your 3BR pencils against current average rent across Orlando's neighborhoods — and price it like the new-build pipeline you've been competing with is about to dry up. Because it is.

Did Avalon Park rents hold up against the Orlando metro headwind?

For the most part, yes.

Metro-wide apartment vacancy doesn't describe Avalon Park's SFR stock. It describes apartment towers, and Avalon Park's SFR market sits in a different universe.

For a comparable East-Orlando view, our Lake Nona neighborhood guide breaks down a similar 2025 story with different specifics.

Who's renting in Avalon Park heading into 2026?

The same three groups, and all three held up in 2025.

UCF's fall 2025 enrollment hit 70,674 students — the largest of any university in Florida — per the UCF Facts page. UCF Off-Campus Partners lists "Waterford / Avalon" as a recognized housing zone, and Avalon Park's shared-SFR niche for upper-class students kept its demand baseline through the year. You won't fill a 5BR Avalon Park house on the family market — but you can fill it with four UCF juniors who want a yard and a Publix walkable from the front door.

The school-driven family demand stayed strong. Timber Creek High School at 1001 Avalon Park Boulevard is rated highly on Public School Review's Timber Creek listing, with a graduation rate above the Florida average. Avalon Elementary and Avalon Middle round out a top-tier feeder pattern. For a 3BR family-market rental, that's the single most important underwriting variable, and it didn't move.

The employer base didn't move either. Lockheed Martin and L3Harris on Research Parkway are a 15-to-20-minute commute. Medical City is closer. Defense contractors, university staff, and healthcare workers were the renter mix in 2024, and they were the renter mix in 2025.

If you own remotely, this is the most verifiable renter mix in Orlando. UCF enrollment numbers, FLDOE school grades, and employer locations are all on the public record. What you can't verify from a thousand miles away is HOA enforcement mood — and Avalon Park's covenants vary by phase, with several phases having tightened lease-approval and short-term-rental rules over 2024–2025. That's where a local manager who reads the HOA meeting minutes is the difference between a clean year and a finable one.

What should an Avalon Park landlord do now?

Three moves heading into 2026, in priority order.

First, underwrite the next 24 months with no new local SFR supply. The Stanley Martin townhomes are sale product, the senior building isn't new SFR supply, and there's nothing else in the 32828 development pipeline. That's a real shift, and renewal letters should reflect it. Don't ask for moonshot increases — the metro is still soft on apartments and your renter sees those ads. But don't roll over either. The supply backdrop that justified flat renewals in 2024 isn't the same backdrop heading into 2027.

Second, price against single-family comparables, not apartment specials. Pull three or four recently signed leases on Avalon Park 3BRs — actual signed prices, not asking prices — and anchor there. Metro apartment vacancy isn't the comp set for a house with a yard near an A-rated school.

Third, check your HOA rules. Several Avalon Park phases tightened lease-approval timelines and short-term-rental restrictions over the past 24 months. If you bought before 2023 and haven't read the updated covenants, read them now. For a homeowners' association, Florida Statute 720.306(1)(h)1. says: "Except as otherwise provided in this paragraph, any governing document, or amendment to a governing document, that is enacted after July 1, 2021, and that prohibits or regulates rental agreements applies only to a parcel owner who acquires title to the parcel after the effective date of the governing document or amendment, or to a parcel owner who consents, individually or through a representative, to the governing document or amendment." Subparagraph 2. adds that "an association may amend its governing documents to prohibit or regulate rental agreements for a term of less than 6 months and may prohibit the rental of a parcel for more than three times in a calendar year, and such amendments shall apply to all parcel owners." The paragraph has further exceptions, for associations of 15 or fewer parcel owners and for transfers to an affiliated entity or an heir, so check each amendment's date against when you took title before assuming it binds you. Our broader writeup on HOA rental restrictions in Florida covers the statewide layer; the Avalon Park-specific layer requires pulling the recorded amendments for your phase.

Avalon Park spent 2025 closing the book on its development era. The next chapter — the first time in 28 years there's no master plan producing new inventory behind your rental — starts now. If you'd like a clear read on what your 32828 home should rent for against that backdrop, our team's free rental analysis walks it through comp by comp.